Beware, there are spoilers here for The First Law trilogy, specifically the ending of A Last Argument of Kings.

A Red Country is the next novel set in Joe Abercrombie’s popular fantasy world that readers first discovered in The First Law trilogy. With Abercrombie recently finishing a first draft of the novel, and some interesting news about the plot, I thought it would be a good time to go over the details of what we know about A Red Country.

First, we have this early synopsis from Abercrombie’s blog, from February 2012:

Shy South comes home to her farm to find a blackened shell, her brother and sister stolen, and knows she’ll have to go back to bad old ways if she’s ever to see them again. She sets off in pursuit with only her cowardly old step-father Lamb for company. But it turns out he’s hiding a bloody past of his own. None bloodier. Their journey will take them across the lawless plains, to a frontier town gripped by gold fever, through feuds, duels, and massacres, high into unmapped mountains to a reckoning with ancient enemies, and force them into alliance with Nicomo Cosca, infamous soldier of fortune, a man no one should ever have to trust…

While the confirmed conclusion of Nicomo Cosca was pleasing (he’s one of Joe’s more convincing creations, if you ask me), the real discussion was centred around the few sentences describing Shy’s namless uncle: “She sets off in pursuit with only her cowardly old step-father Lamb for company. But it turns out he’s hiding a bloody past of his own. None bloodier.”

The repetition of the word “bloody” led many fans to believe that Shy’s uncle was none other than Logen Ninefingers, also known as “The Bloody Nine,” whose fate was left unclear at the end of The First Law trilogy. Since then, Abercrombie’s been asked of Logen’s fate in nearly ever interview he’s conducted, always replying with non-committal phrases and a cute wink.

This speculation was re-ignited and by a new synopsis, released in the Gollancz Fall catalog, revealed by Stomping on Yeti, that all but reveals the fate of Logen Ninefingers:

His name is Logen Ninefingers. And he’s back for one more adventure…

Joe Abercrombie is the most successful genre novelist of his generation, with a remarkable, cynical and powerful voice cutting through the clichés of the fantasy genre to create something compelling and exceptionally commercial. A Red Country is his most powerful novel yet.

Set thirteen years after the end of Last Argument of Kings, A Red Country finally looks to tell the story of Logen Ninefinger’s fate. In one way, I’m sort of sad to see Logen again and think that, if anyone, he deserved to pass his time quietly out-of-sight, though, with his history, and The Bloody Nine always lurking in the shadows, it’s no surprise that he couldn’t hide away through his twilight years. He was already aging and world-weary during The First Law trilogy, so I’m curious to see how he’s evolved and/or mellowed in the years since.

Fans have been clamouring for confirmation of Logen’s “death” for years, and Abercrombie has been determinedly tight-lipped about the situation, so why reveal that information through a small blurb in a catalog, rather than surprising fans with it in the text of the novel? Basically, these catalogs are created with the intention of building buzz within the bookseller/librarian/reviewer world. Logen is one of Abercrombie’s most popular characters and his inclusion in the novel is more likely to catch the attention of those influential people, spoilers be-damned, who ultimately determine the success of a novel. Of course, in this day and age, that information ends up here, on the blog, for regular fans of the series to read, spoilers, again, be-damned.

A earlier blog post from Abercrombie had an interesting tidbit about one of the POV characters in the novel:

I’ve made quite a significant change to the personality of one of my two central characters – or perhaps not a change but a clarification, a shift of emphasis and a refinement of style – and he seems to be working quite a bit better now. In essence, I’ve made him a bit more of a shit than he was before, which tends to be a fruitful direction for me to go in with characters on the whole. Who knew?

So, is that Cosca or Logen? Any guesses?

Abercrombie himself also has some interesting observations about the structure of the novel, which sees the POV characters reduced from a large handful to just two for the majority of the novel:

With Red Country I wanted to try something slightly different, and work with two central points of view plus an occasional third. By the time I’d written two parts that way, though, I was starting to think that was feeling a bit claustrophobic, and that even though I was aiming at a more stripped down, simple, focused style of story, I was missing a trick by not applying that extras approach to some sections of this book. So in the third, fourth, and fifth parts I did some major scenes in that style of rapid movement between minor players. Now I need to write a new sequence in that style to go in the second part, and rewrite a sequence that was previously from one point of view to be from many.

One of my major criticisms of Best Served Cold was that I felt Abercrombie was too comfortable with the tricks that made The First Law trilogy compelling. I said:

Best Served Cold is Abercrombie’s attempt to out-Abercrombie himself and everything is meaner and bloodier than last time; even the shades of grey have been left behind in favour of blood spattered black.

Now, I don’t expect the nihilism and general bloodiness to go away or lessen in A Red Country, but I am happy to see that Abercrombie is continuing to push himself in terms of story structure by eschewing the larger cast of POV characters for a tighter focus, allowing him to dig more deeply into these characters. It will be interesting to see how that affects my attachment to the characters and how I respond to the sections of the novel that pull back and feature a quick smattering of several points of view. It’s an ambitious attempt, which I admire.

For further hints at A Red Country and some great discussion with Joe himself, check out this episode of the Fantasy Faction podcast from February, 2012.

A Red Country is set for a Fall 2012 release.

  • Doug M. March 30, 2012 at 12:25 pm

    I’ve only ever wanted Abercrombie to kill him off unreservedly or to bring him back again. I’d have been happy with either, but the shameless pimping of Logen’s limbo status in the previous two stand-alone novels needed to stop one way or the other. Enough is enough. I’m glad he finally made up his mind which it was going to be. ;)

    Looking forward to it.

  • alabrave March 30, 2012 at 2:26 pm

    It’s funny you used the term “out-Abercrombie” that was exactly what I said to someone when they asked me if they should keep reading him after First Law. Best Served Cold, while a good read, really is his attempt at being even more cynical and nihilistic than the First Law was, to the point of ridiculousness.

  • Dave Wagner March 31, 2012 at 10:23 pm

    While I thought BSC was a small step away from what made me love Abercrombie after First Law, I think he more than redeemed himself with The Heroes, which (after a recent re-read) has solidified its place in my Favorite Books List. For some reason, I really connect with Abercrombie and his voice/style… I’ll buy Red Country the second it’s available, for sure. And now that I know the Bloody Nine will be back, my enthusiasm has redoubled. Thanks for the great post.

  • Luis Beltran March 31, 2012 at 10:31 pm

    Just one of the best literary characters ever created in my opinion, so glad he’s finally back.

  • Mike May 1, 2012 at 5:25 am

    Some other neat tidbits about Logan returning can be found in the trailer, pause at about :18 and you’ll notice that the bloody handprints only have 9 fingers. Just an odd observation. I’m wondering how “old” Lamb is, because seriously, Logan was no spring chicken in the First Law series. I’m going to be pretty miffed if Logan has to stop every 4 hours to take his medication.

  • Saajan Patel July 11, 2012 at 8:10 am

    As someone who had the same issues with BSC, I can say with confidence that Heroes reaches a new high watermark for Joe.

  • Stewart September 12, 2012 at 3:08 am

    I’ve just read the First Law Trilogy and BSC one after the other in the last 3 weeks. I am half way through Heroes atm. While, clearly, I’ve enjoyed them and I do like Abercrombie’s writing style, I was slightly disappointed with the end of the First Law trilogy. it just all seemed to open ended to me, with very little finality on any of the story arcs.

    I’m glad we’re getting some more on Ninefingers, as he was a brilliantly devised character. While the literary device of ending the series as it began was nice, it was also annoying in character terms.

    I like the way he has a continuity of characters, and oblique references to them and plots points previous novels.I’m wondering if Ferro Maljinn will get a novel of her own. The fact she was back home killing eaters was referenced nicely in BSC.

  • cyle anderson September 28, 2012 at 12:37 am

    I’d love to see a prequel telling the story of Logen’s evolution to the bloody nine, especially his battles with Threetrees, Grim and the other fellas.

  • Daniel Crabb October 28, 2012 at 7:23 pm

    Just finished red country, awesome. not putting any spoilers here but there are plenty of surprises in this one :D not sure why so many people having a go at best served cold, brilliant book in my opinion, i reckon Abercrombie knows what he’s doing with these books and i hope he keeps doing it.

  • tone February 9, 2013 at 7:46 am

    I do not what to be bloody opposite the rest. I do find logen ninefingers the best character i ever read about but…. the real.main character is carl shivers

  • Hjd March 2, 2014 at 11:56 am

    IMO, BSC was my favorite novel of all the books prior to Red Country, just started Red Country so can claim that one as my favorite yet! Something about a vengeful bad ass woman that gets me going! First Law trilogy are classics as is The Heroes, but BSC gave us the back story to how Shivers became so cold & ruthless! Logen, Monza Murcatto, Shivers, Whirrun of Bligh, and last but not least Nicomo Cosca, the best characters of JA books! IMO I would love to see a series of books about Cosca, he is one of the funniest, wittiest, and downright luckiest SOBs to ever grace a fantasy novel. His whole smart ass carefree banter is priceless! I would find myself laughing out loud at some of the stuff he would say in BSC! Truly a gem of a character!

  • Ag28078 May 28, 2015 at 4:33 pm

    Honestly, I personally felt that the First Law Trilogy fell flat at the end. While, I did enjoy the many twists that came with the novel the ending was plain. Logen disappeared like a coward (disliked this with a passion) and Bayas got away with no damage even though he was the real villain. I began to read BSC, but stopped when I realized there were different characters. Overall, I consider the First Law Trilogy as one of my favorites. I am excited to see Logen is back, but I feel like it is a bit too late for him. Would have been nice to have seen more of him earlier.